Knowledgebase
Japanese Maple Help #948635
Asked November 19, 2026, 2:36 PM EST
Worcester County Maryland
Expert Response
One common issue Japanese maples have in our region is damage from winter weather. Our climate is a bit hard on them, as they do best in more mild (summer and winter) climates like the Pacific Northwest, where many wholesale nurseries that propagate them are located. Sometimes, we have a late winter warm-up followed by a freeze (as happened this past April) which can damage lots of otherwise-hardy plants. In part, that happens because the warm spell makes them break dormancy, and once that happens, they lose the degree of cold-hardiness needed to withstand additional freezes. (The process that gets their tissues ready for cold exposure in winter starts many weeks prior to the onset of freezing weather, so they don't have time to regain that much cold tolerance after those warm spells.) Bark can crack or the cambium (the live wood just under the bark, which keeps the canopy hydrated and fed) can die if exposed to too much of a cold snap or temperature swing. Japanese maples are one of several tree species with comparatively thin bark, making them more vulnerable.
Another factor that might be overlapping with weather damage is an opportunistic infection like Botryosphaeria canker. This fungus takes advantage of stressed trees and shrubs, and the resulting infection can kill branches over time, and might even affect the trunk. Common precursors to infection are stress from drought and high heat, but could also include winter injury. Maryland has been in a drought for most of the past two years, and despite abating a little earlier this autumn, it's been worsening again in many areas (see the linked map). Your county isn't super dry currently, but it was under a more significant degree of drought earlier this year. Japanese maples are not highly drought-tolerant, so depending on whether they were being watered occasionally, that might be a contributing factor.
As for why some of the trees are damaged and others are fine, there can be a variety of reasons. Microclimate (environmental conditions like temperature and soil moisture) can vary across the yard and from one property to another, and just a few degrees of temperature change can make a big difference in a plant's vulnerability to damage. The same is true for soil moisture available to the roots. Plus, different cultivars of Japanese maple have different genetics and may be more or less tolerant to certain stresses than others.
It also depends on the structure of each tree's root system from the time it was first planted. Girdling roots, for example, are a common problem with shallow-rooted trees like maples, and planting a tree too deeply or over-mulching it can promote their formation (although often there are already some developing before a tree is planted, because trees can become buried too deeply in their pots or burlap at the nursery). We don't see a root flare on the tree whose trunk is pictured, and the root flare should be situated at or just above the soil surface. As they worsen, girdling roots can "strangle" each other or the trunk base below the soil line where they are not visible, and once that advances too far, there is no remedy. The linked pages have more information. Although it might not make much difference in the tree's health at this point, you could see if you can locate the flare on the tree with the badly-cracked trunk. Our guess is it is several inches below the current soil/mulch surface.
Early leaf drop is a sure sign of plant stress. While so far it has leafed-out in spring, the degree of trunk cracking suggests it may not do so again, or not for much longer. Unfortunately there is nothing you can do to fix that, although you can stop fertilizing. Trees, shrubs, and most perennials do not need regular or annual fertilization unless their foliage is showing signs of a nutrient deficiency (and other factors have been ruled-out, like improper soil acidity). A laboratory soil test is the only way to measure if a deficiency is present. While the fertilization you've been doing didn't directly cause the problem affecting the trees now, it isn't helping them either and applying too many nutrients that the soil is not deficient in can eventually harm roots and the beneficial soil microbes that they rely on to stay vigorous and healthy.
Miri