Hello, A few years ago I noticed black and white patches around the base of my White Oak tree. I had a tree guy (Bartlett Trees) suggest that it might...
Knowledgebase
Tree Fungus Identification #948597
Asked November 18, 2026, 2:31 PM EST
Hello, A few years ago I noticed black and white patches around the base of my White Oak tree. I had a tree guy (Bartlett Trees) suggest that it might be Kretzschmaria deusta (Brittle Cinder Fungus). Since then the white patches have slowly gone away and now it is just black and crispy looking. When I crush the fungus it looks like charcoal. I haven't removed the tree because other tree people have told me that the canopy looks fine and they thought I should leave it (none of them had heard of this disease). The cost to remove the tree is also prohibitive. However, I'm concerned that it might fall on my neighbors house and I don't want anyone to get hurt; it's a very big tree. I am attaching photos and hoping you might help me determine what to do or maybe suggest a lab that might analyze a sample of the tissue for me. Any help would be greatly appreciated.
Montgomery CountyMaryland
Expert Response
An arborist would likely be more able to make a diagnosis of Brittle Cinder Fungus in person, as identifying tree problems from photos is difficult, but lab testing is probably not necessary since there is no treatment/cure for such infections. Since this type of fungus (which does sound like a plausible diagnosis from the photos and your description) is a pathogen that kills live wood, even if the canopy currently looks ok, wood decay is present if the fungus is evident. We recommend that an arborist who has tools to detect internal decay in the trunk examine the tree. While that may add to the cost of having it evaluated, there is no other way (short of proactively having the tree cut down if it will be a hazard to nearly structures) to deal with that type of fungal threat.
As the University of Massachusetts notes, "Minimally-invasive decay detection techniques, such as resistance drilling and sonic tomography, are often required to understand the full extent of the decay. A basal trunk application of phosphites may help to slow the progression of the disease into the sapwood and cambium, but ultimately the tree will die as a result of the disease." If budget is a concern and an arborist confirms wood decay in the trunk is present, then you may want to forego any decline-delaying treatments since they have limited impact and in the end will not eliminate the need to eventually pay to have the tree cut down so it doesn't fall.
Some tree companies have their own diagnostic lab if they are able to take samples to confirm which fungus is present (if possible...not all labs have the ability to screen for every possible pathogen or decay organism). Or, an arborist might be able to get help from the UMD plant diagnostic lab, although in that case the person should contact the lab first to ask if this is a fungal ID they can verify.