Knowledgebase

Nothing grows here #928302

Asked April 13, 2026, 5:44 PM EDT

What can we do with this muddy area? We’ve re-seeded multiple times and the grass just dies. It’s muddy when it rains, and dusty when it’s very dry in the summer. Clay soil. There’s a bit of a slope, and the rest of the lawn drains into this area. The grassy strip on the far side of the daffodil bed belongs to our neighbor. The wooded area on the left, and the daffodil bed on the right belong to us. The muddy area is also ours. Mulch or stones would be very expensive. Are there any plants that would do OK in this environment? Thank you!

Mahoning County Ohio

Expert Response

Good Morning Helen,

Thank you for reaching out - and know you are not alone in your challenges with Ohio's clay soils! Clay-based soils tend to shuck water more frequently than loam or silt soils, simply because of compaction and fine particle size - leading to that crusty appearance in the hot summer months, and sticky or constantly wet in the spring rain season (once clay soils are thoroughly soaked, they may take a while to dry out). So, long story short, it is possible to seed lawn or plant ornamentals into those areas, it may just require some additional management: 

- First, I would recommend a soil test.  Even with the addition of topsoil or amendments, if the pH or nutrient levels are out of optimum range, you may still experience challenges getting anything to grow.  We offer soil testing through our office, with more information here: https://mahoning.osu.edu/program-areas/agriculture-and-natural-resources/soil-testing

- Second, this area would likely benefit from the introduction of topsoil, or organic matter such as compost, peat, or a similar material. Incorporating topsoil and rototilling can be a straightforward way to break up the clay layer and create more soil permeability.  Step-by-step guide here: https://buckeyeturf.osu.edu/news/turfgrass-establishment-series-seedbed-preparation


If you have any additional questions, feel free to reach out to me directly at <personal data hidden>. Thank you!

An Ask Extension Expert Replied April 14, 2026, 10:21 AM EDT

Loading ...