Knowledgebase

Amending Clay Soil #894701

Asked March 17, 2025, 4:51 PM EDT

Hi MSU Extension, We have a large suburban yard, with a lot of shade. Over the years it seems to have become more and more compacted. When I dig in it, it does not take long to reach clay. I've had it aerated twice now (in the Spring and Fall) and have used Spring and Fall fertilizer. I have a dog, and kids use the yard regularly. I'm trying to figure out what would help the most. Would gypsum or mycorrhizal fungi help break up the clay at all? It's never going to be thick and lush, but it's reaching the point where I'm worried this season the grass is going to die. I mulch a large part of the leaves into the yard, and would like to use minimal chemicals.

Kent County Michigan

Expert Response

Thank you for your question.  From your photos I'm concluding you have a fair amount of shade and you noted it's a play yard for both kids and pets.  Both conditions are hard on grass.
My first suggestion is to do a soil test (something you can do now).  Knowing the type and fertility of your soil is the starting point to establishing & maintaining a strong turf that can resist diseases, weeds, shade, moss and insects/grubs and look great without wasting material or $. More info here: Don't Guess-Soil Test-MSU and MSU Home Soil Test-self mailer Soil test results will identify any soil deficiencies that you can work to correct, improving turf health, making it more resistant to grub damage.
Adding gypsum does not work well in Michigan soils.  See the attached article: (https://www.canr.msu.edu/news/gypsum_as_a_soil_additive_use_it_or_lose_it.  Plus you need to mix it in with the clay somehow (core aeration or reseeding the yard).
I'd suggest core aeration with a topdressing of 1) a seed mix containing several fescue and Kentucky Bluegrass cultivars  and 2) compost, that are raked over the surface after aeration.  You will also want to apply a half dose of starter fertilizer and irrigate for several weeks.  This is best done in early fall in warm soil when cooler air temperatures and fall rains come and there is less weed pressure.  Traffic should be kept off the seeded area until it is well established.  Knowing there are kids and pets you might consider doing part of the lawn this spring and the balance in the fall, KNOWING you'll need to water the spring seeded part over the summer.
More info on core aeration and lawn seeding in the attached links:
Turfgrass species ID & Cultivar Selection (E2912)-MSU
Improving Lawns in The Shade-Purdue
Core Aeration of Lawns-MSU
Core Aeration of lawns-Illinois
Growing Turf Under Shaded Conditions-PSU
Establishing A New Lawn Using Seed (E2910)-MSU - can also be used for overseeding/renovation
Renovating A Lawn for Quality & sustainability-UMN
Spring Reseeding Tips-MSU
Smart Lawns Tip Sheets-MSU  
Dick M. Replied March 19, 2025, 2:53 PM EDT

Loading ...