Knowledgebase

Milkweed Experiment #891954

Asked January 26, 2025, 6:05 PM EST

Hi, I am a high school student at Washburn and I am designing an experiment for my biology class. My research question is related to the effects of different salt solutions on the germination of red milkweed seeds. I expect that high concentrations of salt will prevent the seeds from germinating. Here are my questions: 1) Will milkweed seeds germinate if they are placed in water? Or do you think I should put them in soil? I also have seen filter paper mentioned in some studies. 2) How long would it normally take for a milkweed seed to germinate? 3) With milkweed seeds, do I have to do the cold stratification? I read something about this online. Or can I just put them in soil or water? If cold stratification is required, I think it will take too long for me to complete the experiment. Is there a different seed I could use that is native to Minnesota and pollinator friendly? Thank you!

Hennepin County Minnesota

Expert Response

Thanks for your question.  It has been assigned to me.  I will be glad to assist you.  However, I do need one little bit of information from you.  Where are you getting your milkweed seeds?  This is important for me to decided if stratification will be necessary.

Thanks so much.

An Ask Extension Expert Replied January 27, 2025, 7:53 PM EST
Hi, 

Thanks for replying. I bought them from Prairie Nursery in Wisconsin. https://www.prairienursery.com/



On Mon, Jan 27, 2025 at 6:53 PM Ask Extension <<personal data hidden>> wrote:
The Question Asker Replied February 27, 2025, 9:13 PM EST

Thanks for getting back to me.

1). For milkweed seeds to germinate, they need first to be exposed to cold temperatures for a period of time. This is termed stratification. If you were to plant seeds that had not undergone this process, they may not germinate. Even if you use seeds from a commercial seed company, they still may need stratification. That was why it was important for me to know where you got your seeds. I have looked at the Prairie Nursery site. It appears that seeds obtained from them should undergo moist stratification. If you already have these seeds, there should have been instructions included for doing this type of stratification. If you attempt to germinate your milkweed seeds without doing this, they may not germinate. This stratification is the most important thing for you to do for the success of your project. Here is some information from Prairie Nursery for doing this.

https://www.prairienursery.com/resources-guides/seed-stratification/ - :~:text=A moist stratification seed treatment,ten days to three months.

2). Your seeds may develop a few small roots if you place them in water but probably no leaves. It would be best to use a soil mixture. See the following:

https://www.wildflower.org/learn/how-to/how-to-germinate-milkweeds - :~:text=Well-draining growing mix.,bark (can add coarse sand)

3). If you have stratified your seeds and planted them in soil, you should see emergence of shoots within 10 days. Put the pot with your seeds in a warm area.

4). Stratification should be complete after two or three weeks. If you start this process ASAP and then plant your seeds, I believe that you should have some results by the first of May.

With respect to your experiment, I would suggest that you use five separate pots, all the same size. Label these pots as #1, #2, #3, #4, and #5. Plant the same number of seeds (maybe eight?) in each pot. Have your different salt concentrations in the water that you use for watering purposes. Do NOT mix the salt directly with the soil. Use common table salt. Also get five 1-quart containers. Do the following:

Container #1: 1 quart of fresh water, no salt.

Container #2: 1 quart of fresh water containing 1/8 cup of salt; mix well

Container #3: 1 quart of fresh water containing 1/4 cup of salt; mix well

Container #4: 1 quart of fresh water containing 3/8 cup of salt; mix well

Container #5: 1 quart of fresh water containing 1/2 cup of salt; mix well

Label your pots #1, #2, #3, #4, #5. Pot #1 will be your “control pot” and against which you will compare the results from the other four pots. Start watering the pots with water from each of containers at the time you plant the seeds (water from container #1 to pot #1, and so forth). This will be your “day zero”. Water each pot with same amount of water every three days. “Day 3” will be the third day you water after planting the seeds. “Day 6” three days after “day 3, and so on.

Be sure you keep daily observational records. Record this information for each day of your experiment.

This should be a fun thing to do. Let me suggest one additional thing. If you observe effects upon germination and growth, try to figure out what is causing these effects.

Good luck. Get back to me if you have any questions. I would love to get any pics of your project as it progresses.

An Ask Extension Expert Replied February 28, 2025, 10:50 AM EST

Loading ...