Knowledgebase

Roasted Tomatoes #883542

Asked August 30, 2024, 1:15 PM EDT

In a past response that I found (#804166) dated Aug of 2022, I feel that the response may have been a bit ambiguous and didn't fully answer the question. May I ask for clarification if the extension response was more about the safety of canning whole, half, or quartered tomatoes vs. the pureed sauce in the original question? I too would like to know if it is safe to roast tomatoes prior to making just sauce or paste if the remaining liquid is included in the sauce.

Lane County Oregon

Expert Response

I should also mention that I want to roast fresh tomatoes with skin on and run them through a food mill to remove skin and seeds after the roasting process is completed, then continue with the NCHFP recipe for sauce or paste.

The Question Asker Replied August 30, 2024, 1:19 PM EDT
Hi Les, I dug around and found both the Ask Extension question you mentioned and the original one it connected to.  The original one was answered in 2022 by Glenda Hyde of central Oregon Extension, the absolute pro and authority I would trust for your answer.  She even mentions a conversation she had with the director of the NCHFP, who shared that "roasting tomatoes is not a safe method for removing skins from tomatoes in any of their recipes for canning tomatoes."

So I would encourage you to follow directions-as-written for any canned tomato product, and save the roasted approach for either freezing sauce or a fresh sauce to consume within a day or so.  

See below:


Roasting tomatoes and using food mill? #804166

Asked August 01, 2022, 9:23 PM EDT

I’d like to can tomato purée by roasting halved tomatoes, running the roasted tomatoes and juices through a food mill, and then water bath or pressure canning (adding the appropriate amount of citric acid per jar). I’ve read many approved tomato canning recipes, and their treatments of skin and food mills varies so much that I’m having a difficult time determining if my proposed method is safe. Your help is very much appreciated!

Multnomah County Oregon

Expert Response

Hi Laura. We recommend you follow the directions from reliable resources such as those at the National Center for Home Food Preservation (NCHFP). You can find the USDA Complete Guide to Home Canning linked on their web page, free to view or download. Print copies can be obtained from Purdue Extension - ONLY. There are bootleg copies being sold in stores and on Amazon that are not safe. The USDA does not sell this product in commercial settings. Also available at the NCHFP is a link to the So Easy to Preserve products. Recipe books and a video series are produced by the University of Georgia Extension.

In the Pacific Northwest, OSU, UIdaho and WSU Extension have jointly produced a Pacific North West (PNW) series that better helps residents understand the USDA Complete Guide to Home Canning recipes with additional tips, clarifications and allowable substitutions. Most recent revisions also include photos of some key steps. See PNW 300 Tomatoes and Tomato Products. You can find it and many more of our publications free to view or download at https://beav.es/OSUFoodPreservation.

In a recent conversation with the director of the NCHFP, she shared that roasting tomatoes is not a safe method for removing skins from tomatoes in any of their recipes for canning tomatoes. Liquid amounts, added acid measurements and processing times may no longer be sufficient for a safe product. Quality changes can occur, too. OSU Extension supports the NCHFP statement and does not recommend roasting tomatoes before canning either.

We think Ball has two recipes with roasted tomatoes that have been tested in their lab. They do not recommend interchanging this process with any of their other recipes. If you decide to use these recipes, follow the directions exactly.

Suspect jars of canned tomatoes should be detoxified or disposed in a safe method to prevent the risk of botulism. See PNW 300 for directions. Glenda Hyde, Associate Professor of Practice Replied August 02, 2022, 3:45 PM EDT




An Ask Extension Expert Replied September 03, 2024, 1:11 PM EDT

Loading ...