Knowledgebase
Can you please help, identifying and remedy of this disease on our tree? Thanks! #868794
Asked May 16, 2024, 7:02 PM EDT
Howard County Maryland
Expert Response
Miri
Without an image of the entire tree to see how badly the leaf loss is affecting it (or if there is an infection present), it's hard to say if it's salvageable. If weed'n'feed is applied yearly to the lawn, and if the tree is mostly surrounded by lawn, then its exposure is much greater than just a 3- to 4-foot zone around the trunk. For a tree nearly 25 years old, its roots will extend far out from the trunk, well past the canopy edges, so if lawn occupies much of that area, the dosage of herbicide exposure (if that is what is contributing to dieback) is large enough that it could be causing widespread canopy decline. Some herbicide ingredients are more damaging to tree roots than others; dicamba, for instance, is one of them that can cause significant injury.
Fertilizer is not recommended for a plant in decline, as it has the potential to worsen the situation and the roots, if they are ailing already, will not be able to make use of the supplemental nutrients. Plus, it's unlikely that the soil itself is deficient enough in most needed nutrients such that fertilizer will make much of a difference. While the application you already made can't be undone, for the future, we suggest that a plant that is struggling not be fertilized unless a distinct nutrient deficiency is the only cause of discolored leaves or poor growth.
Bradford pears and other Callery pear cultivars are invasive trees, having spread widely in Maryland natural areas, and we discourage gardeners from growing them. Therefore, if this tree has enough decline that recovery is unlikely, we recommend removing it and replacing it with a native (or at least non-invasive) species. Since it sounds like there are hardly any leaves on the tree, it is definitely too weak to expect recovery, nor is it treatable, though you could always hire a certified arborist to consult who can assess the tree in person and try to determine what began the decline. It almost certainly wasn't a canopy infection (though a less-serious twig infection is still possible as an overlapping issue), but likely began either in the root zone or as damage (from weather, insects, injury, etc.) to the trunk.
Miri