Knowledgebase

Lowering PH with Sulfur in Fall #850021

Asked September 15, 2023, 11:19 AM EDT

My soil tests at 8.2 Ph - I read conflicting advice about using sulfur in the fall to help it over the winter. I bought the sulfur - I have about 60 square feet of raised beds but now I am questioning should I do this or not because of temperature. Thank you

Hennepin County Minnesota

Expert Response

Thanks for the question.  But need some information from you.  What pH would you like to obtain in your gardens and what are some of the plants in them?  Also if you have a copy of the soil test, could you please take a picture of it and send to us?

Thanks for consulting us.

An Ask Extension Expert Replied September 15, 2023, 8:43 PM EDT
Thank you! I guess we would like about a Ph of 7? We grow/grew bush beans, sugar snaps, pole beans, lettuce, arugula, a couple of tomatoes and a couple pepper plants. We have a herb garden (which didn’t seem affected at all) and a million zinnias and marigolds and nasturtiums. The flowers got over 3 feet tall. Everything seemed somewhat normal except I had issues with the beans which made me start wondering about diseases or pests. Attaching a copy of soil test. Oh, and this is our first year and we did the Hugelkultur method and used year old horse manure. We fertilized just a couple times with Epsom Biotone Starter Slow Release but only when I remembered so wasn’t much. I added Bone Meal on the side to a couple things and Fish Fertilizer to a couple things also but nothing on a schedule like it should have been. The sugar snaps started out great and climbed about 2 ft and then the roots and leaves turned yellow and wilted but the middle and top was green and producing (not much but healthy) The bush beans didn’t produce first planting except the Goldmine Wax beans. The third and last planting of bush (green) beans just produced a week ago and still going. The pole beans had a ton of leaves but finally produced. The prolific leaves started me wondering also.
Thanks very much for advice!20230916_195153.jpeg

On Sep 15, 2023, at 7:43 PM, Ask Extension <<personal data hidden>> wrote:

The Question Asker Replied September 16, 2023, 10:03 PM EDT

Thanks for the response. Lowering the pH to 7 is going to be a real challenge for you.  It is  goal that may take at least two or three years  Since the pH scale is logarithmic, you will be attempting to obtain a pH that is more than 90% lower than what it currently is.  I will have to look into the best way, if possible, of doing that.  A pH of 7.5 or so would certainly meet the needs of what you want to grow.

Unfortunately the picture of the soil test only showed a portion of the first page of the report.  If possible, take the picture with a landscape orientation so that I can see the full extent of the report.

Many thanks for doing this.

An Ask Extension Expert Replied September 17, 2023, 1:03 AM EDT
OK, here’s hopefully what you asked for. By the way, it’s four 4x16  and two 4x8 beds - one of which has the herbs. I have to switch the crops to different beds next year right?
Thankssoiltest2.jpeg20230917_002517.jpeg 

On Sep 17, 2023, at 12:03 AM, Ask Extension <<personal data hidden>> wrote:

The Question Asker Replied September 17, 2023, 5:20 AM EDT

Thanks for getting back to us. I apologize for my tardiness in responding.

I am puzzled why you think you need to switch crops to different beds. Perhaps when you get a chance, you can clarify this?

Two other comments. Although I have never used Hugelkultur, some of my gardening friends have done so with great success. Your soil has a rather high organic content (this is good!) of 10.2%. This reflects your Hegelkultur approach. Secondly, I would suggest that you no longer use horse manure. Horse manure contains lime and can raise the pH of the soil, which is just the opposite of what you want to do. See:

https://agriculture.okstate.edu/departments-programs/plant-soil/soil-testing/site-files/docs/publications/pt98-7-manure-raises-soilph.pdf

I do not know what type of sulfur you intend to use. You have three choices: elemental sulfur (100% sulfur), ammonium sulfate (22% sulfur), or iron sulfate (12% to 16% sulfur). Any of these should be available at most gardening centers. Do NOT use aluminum sulfate. Elemental sulfur would be best and the easiest to use. The type of sulfur used is important in determining how much to use. See:

https://www.gardeningknowhow.com/garden-how-to/soil-fertilizers/sulfur-in-plants.htm - :~:text=Sulfur is as necessary as,problems and loss of vitality.

Here is where, I think, we stand. You currently have four 4x16 foot raised beds. Each bed then is 64 square feet. Your two 4x8 raised beds each has 32 square feet. Presumably the pH in each of these beds is 8.2. For ease in calculations, I propose that the goal should be to lower the soil pH in each to about 7.2 (1 pH unit). As I’ve previously indicated, this will not be a quick process. It may take two or three years to do so.

1). To lower the pH from 8.2 to 7.2 will require a total of approximately 1 pound of sulfur per 100 square feet. If you use elemental sulfur (the best way to go) this translates into approximately 0.6 pounds of sulfur for each of the 4x16 beds and approximately 0.3 pounds of sulfur for each of the two 4x8 beds. Add half of these amounts this fall (0.3 pounds and 0.15 pounds respectively) ASAP and the other half amounts in spring 2024 as early as possible (early April?) as soon as you can work the soil. Work it into soil thoroughly.

2). If you use ammonium sulfate, add 1.5 pounds this fall and 1.5 pounds next spring to each of the four 4x16 beds. For each of the two 4x8 beds, add about 0.8 pounds this fall and 0.8 pounds in spring 2024.

3). If you use iron sulfate, add 1.8 pounds this fall and 1.8 pounds next spring to each of the four 4x16 beds. For each of the two 4x8 beds, add about 0.9 pounds this fall and 0.9 pounds on spring 2024.

4). As I said, lowering pH can be tricky so try one additional step. Peat moss can lower pH albeit more slowly than sulfur. It also has the advantage of adding to the soil’s organic content. The best peat moss for lowering soil pH is CANADIAN PEAT MOSS. Try to get this if you can. See:

https://hortnews.extension.iastate.edu/how-change-your-soils-ph - :~:text=Sphagnum peat moss is often,will effectively reduce soil pH.

Strategy is to use both sulfur and peat moss together to lower the pH.

In each of the four 4x16 beds, when you add the sulfur this fall, mix the sulfur with 2 to 3 pounds of peat moss. Also, when you add the sulfur in spring 2024, mix it with 2 to 3 pounds of peat moss.

In each of the two 4x8 beds, when you add the sulfur this fall, mix the sulfur with1 to 1.5 pounds of peat moss. Do the same when you add sulfur in spring 2024.

5). After you do the spring 2024 sulfur/peat moss additions wait a couple of weeks but before you do any planting, submit a soil sample to the University’s Soil Testing Laboratory. Let's see what the pH result is. This will be important information from which to see what progress, if any, has been made and as guidance for the 2024 season.

I apologize for all the detail in my answer, but attention needs to be paid to such for effectiveness in lower soil pH. Best of luck and please get back to us with any questions.

An Ask Extension Expert Replied September 22, 2023, 5:37 PM EDT
Thank you for being so detailed! I had read multiple times to switch your crop “families” around so as not to wear out certain nutrient in one spot year after year - but as I’m typing this I’m thinking isn’t that why people add all kinds of fertilizer? To be fair though, I’m not keen on adding a bunch of fertilizer type things but there are organic options and the more serious resasons why make sense. I just have a hard time remembering (and yes I have multiple white boards and calendars) so it was about 50/50 this year. In fact that’s part of reason I’m writing again - so my notes say I should add something before shutting it down to hopefully replenish soil for the spring. Because I did the whole sulfur and peat moss deal I did NOT, but wanted to double check to make sure. I used the Espoma Organic Biotin Starter to start it but also the hardest part is being in Minnesota! Because everything is telling you to put stuff in the GROUND like 2+ months before the last frost and so it’s practically February and come on now….I just dont see how people do it. So now you are telling me to do it in pretty much April but to send my soil in also. I’m sure people are chomping at the bit to get their soil results back and by then you have lost a lot of time I would think. But I understand why of course. Just wondering what things would we normally be doing in the spring that we cannot because of the whole sulfur/peat/soil test wait time?I now have lost almost a whole 16 ft bed to my newbie husbands Strawberries (which thrived in spite of me) and my Toothache plant which thrived the same - I ended up with almost 20 very healthy producing toothache plants which was great but its almost like I’m down a bed already. I did mix the sulfur and peat in the herb bed but AROUND the perennials so not sure how much got through. Got everything else pretty good, plain peat layer on top then cardboard for weeds and straw for insulating. So any advice about “regular” fertilizing on top of this Alkaline problem would be helpful and also clarify the rotating crop thing because I dont know why you haven’t heard this before?
Thanks again - 

On Sep 22, 2023, at 4:41 PM, Ask Extension <<personal data hidden>> wrote:

The Question Asker Replied November 02, 2023, 12:56 PM EDT

Thanks for getting back to me.

Rotating planting on a yearly basis is something that in many cases does NOT need to be done. You were astute enough to question this since, yes, fertilizer is often added annually. The “switching around of crops” is usually NOT because of nutrient deficiency. Sometimes this is done when a plant shows fungal disease, and one does not want in subsequent seasons to keep putting the same plant in the contaminated area. Also, there are plants that over several seasons may produce substances into the soil that are toxic to other plants. To prevent this from happening, such plants are only grown for one or two seasons in a particular area.

I agree with you that sending in soil samples next spring (2024) may encounter some delay in processing. However unless you do this, you will not have any idea as to how successful you have been in lowering soil pH between now (fall 2023) and next spring.

I don’t know where you are reading that fertilizer should be added two months before the last frost. This makes absolutely no sense. As you pointed out this would imply February. Now adding fertilizer a month or so before the first frost would make sense.

You have a valid point about possible delays in planting next spring (2024). The bottom line is the current pH of your raised beds (8.2) is still good for growing most things. Lowering the pH will only make things better. Here’s my point. Do your normal plantings next spring at your usual times whether you have received back the results of the soil analyses or not. If necessary, once these results come in soil amendments can be made. This includes further pH adjustment and/or what kind of fertilizer to apply.

In short, this is my suggested procedure. It largely mirrors what I have previously said to you:

1). Right now (early November 2023) mix into your raised beds the sulfur and peat moss that I previously suggested to you. It sounds as if you have done this already?

2). This fall if possible, cover the surfaces of the raised beds with some bags of leaves. This will add some insulation to your plants over the upcoming winter. Using bags will make their removal next spring much easier.

3). Do not add any fertilizer to your raised beds this fall nor anything else. Think about next spring!

4). In spring 2024 and once the soil in your raised beds has slightly thawed, send in some soil samples for analysis. Try to do this early in April if possible.

5). Hopefully you will get the results back from the soil analyses by early to mid-May. Please take a picture of these results and send to us as a part of your current question thread.

6). Once the soil results are back, decisions can be made as to further pH adjustments and fertilizer additions.

7). As soon as the soil is workable, do your normal spring plantings and seedings even if you are still lacking soil analyses results.

One final point regards the Espoma Bio-tone Starter. It is not completely clear when you last used it and how much you used. Actually, it’s not important. This product contains 4% nitrogen, 3% phosphate, and 3% potash. It would be considered a “4-3-3” fertilizer. It also contains various types of bacterial that facilitate plants’ abilities to take up nutrients. Whether or not you should consider future use of this product awaits the results of the soil analyses. This product is rather low in nitrogen. This may or may not explain why your 2023 bean crop was less than desirable. See:

https://parkseed.com/espoma-bio-tone-starter-plus-4-lb/p/35875/ - :~:text=Formulated to provide plants with,to add in plant growth.

Please get back to me if you want further clarification about what should be done and when.

Good luck.

An Ask Extension Expert Replied November 03, 2023, 6:11 PM EDT
Hi there! I got overanxious about the soil and tried getting as much as I can to send in for another sample. I’m going to try again in a couple weeks just because I’m very very confused now. I’m attaching a picture of the new (2024 Year2) soil test report which amazingly says we went from 8.5 to 7.5 in pH….but now the phosphorus and potassium are OFF the charts! So basically I am supposed to find fertilizer 10-0-0 which seems to only be made for lawns. Otherwise I could put bone meal in everything? I had just bought “pH DOWN” and also some stuff to beef up the minerals and help soil in general called “Optimize” and “Maximize” - organic, from reputable folks so that was maybe a waste of money?
Need your expert opinion if I should try for another sample to see what it says. I couldn’t dig very deep for the sample. Or just plan on adding only nitro - I’m a bit wary of that and the fact I can only find it for lawns, otherwise just add plain bone meal?
Hope this is enough to go on for your advice. I hope you can answer soon, thanks!20240221_212408.jpeg

On Nov 3, 2023, at 5:14 PM, Ask Extension <<personal data hidden>> wrote:

The Question Asker Replied February 22, 2024, 5:27 PM EST

Thanks for your response.  Unfortunately, the picture that you sent of your 2024 soil report is badly out of focus and I can't read any of the numbers.  When you send pictures, they must be in a JPEG format for us to read them.  I also had difficulty in reading the 2023 soil report.  Could you please try to send us pictures of these two reports in a JPEG format?

Many thanks.

An Ask Extension Expert Replied February 25, 2024, 1:32 PM EST
Hi Nathan, re-sending soil report. Anxious to hear what you suggest. Thanks!Year2 Soil.jpeg

On Feb 25, 2024, at 12:32 PM, Ask Extension <<personal data hidden>> wrote:

The Question Asker Replied February 26, 2024, 6:32 PM EST

Thank your for your response.  Unfortunately the picture is still very blurry and out of focus.  This makes it almost impossible for me to respond to you in an accurate fashion.  To see where I'm coming from, perhaps you could print out the picture that you sent me ?  Maybe then you could why I am experiencing difficulty?  Also your response made reference to "Nathan".  I have no idea who this person is.

My guess that the problem lies in the camera and/or lens that you are using.  We get pictures all the time from individuals who use an iPhone without encountering any problems.  What kind of mobile device are you using?

The picture that you sent had a size of only 42KB which is way too small to provide good clarity.  The resolution of 72 pixels/inch is also much too small, which probably explains why things are so blurry.  In short, the picture which you send to me has to be taken with much greater size and resolution.  

Sorry about this.  I'm sure it must be very frustrating for you.


An Ask Extension Expert Replied February 26, 2024, 8:14 PM EST
Sorry about that - here is 2023 soil testYearOne soil.jpeg

On Feb 26, 2024, at 7:14 PM, Ask Extension <<personal data hidden>> wrote:

The Question Asker Replied February 26, 2024, 9:51 PM EST
Year2 Soil.jpeg

On Feb 26, 2024, at 7:14 PM, Ask Extension <<personal data hidden>> wrote:

The Question Asker Replied February 26, 2024, 10:04 PM EST

Thank you for your response. Pictures came through just fine. Will send a more complete analysis later today. 

An Ask Extension Expert Replied February 27, 2024, 8:20 AM EST

Thanks again for your recent pictures and your patience in getting things resolved.

Several issues have been raised since your initial question in September 2023. I think that it is now time to move forward and not dwell too much on past activities. However, I would like to suggest that you refrain from any further use of Bio-Tone Starter and pH Down.

As was mentioned to you in November 2023, Bio-Tone Starter has a very low nitrogen content, which will not promote good growth in your garden. This product has a high bacterial level, which purportedly enhances organic decomposition and nutrient recycling. Given your use of Hügelkultur, your soil probably already has high bacterial and fungal levels and does not need any further bacterial amendments.

It is unclear to me when you started to apply pH Down. This product has a high level of phosphoric acid. If you applied it right before you took your second-year soil sample, this might explain the drop in pH down to 7.5. Since the soil samples from both 2023 and 2024 showed high levels of phosphate, you don’t need to add any more phosphate. This product is really designed for use in hydroponic systems and not for gardens.

I believe that we should focus upon your most recent soil analysis dated 2/19/24. Let me go through things item by item.

1). I see nothing in this most recent analysis to suggest a third analysis should be done. I doubt that any significant, additional information would be forthcoming. Let’s see how things grow during the 2024 season before making any future decisions. Typically soil testing is only done every two or three years.

2). The texture of the soil (medium) is very good. It indicates a good combination of sand and clay. There is no problem here.

3). The organic level of 15.1% is very good. Again this is primarily a reflection of your using Hügelkultur techniques. Continue these techniques. As you noted on the soil report, this organic matter is an excellent source of nitrogen.

4). The reported pH of 7.5 is perfectly adequate for your garden. For purposes of growing things in 2024, don’t worry about adding anything now to adjust the pH. Forget about adding any type of sulfur. In fall 2024, consider digging in some Canadian peat moss as I suggested to you on 9/22/23.

5). When the pH is above 7.4, two different tests (Olsen and Bray) for phosphate are done. Their results taken together are used to determine the total phosphate level of the soil.

6). While the potassium level (300) is high, this rarely causes any problems. Nothing here to worry about.

7). Although the soil has a high organic level, the nitrogen within it may not be readily available for plant growth.  Bacterial and fungal decomposition must first occur. This is why a nitrogen recommendation of 0.15 pounds/100 square feet was indicated.

8). A 10-0-0 fertilizer was suggested for use. It will be difficult to find a fertilizer with this composition. However given your apparent aversion to using chemical fertilizers, let me suggest an alternative – blood meal (NOT bone meal). It can be purchased at most gardening centers. Its nitrogen is “slow releasing”, which means that it could be applied now before you sow any seeds. It will then slowly feed your soil for the next three to four months. A side benefit of it is that it will slowly reduce the soil pH. See:

https://www.earthsciencegrowing.com/expert-advice/blood-meal-101/ - :~:text=Blood meal is one of,undesirable animals out of gardens.

https://www.thespruce.com/blood-meal-uses-benefits-5190065

Typically blood meal contains 13.25% nitrogen, 1% phosphate, and 0.6% potassium. When you buy this product, look at the label to see exactly what the actual percentages are.  This means that blood meal is 13.25-1-0.6, which is very close to the 10-0-0 recommended fertilizer.

It was recommended that you add 0.15 pounds of nitrogen/100 square feet. So if you use blood meal with a nitrogen percentage of around 13%, then in each pound of blood meal there would be 0.13 pounds of nitrogen. Close enough. As soon as you can work the soil in your gardens this spring, dig in a pound of blood meal/100 square feet.

Hopefully, I addressed the various questions you raised. I’ve tried to do this by reducing the number of tasks that should be done while at the same time recognizing your concern about using excessive amounts of chemical compounds.   I applaud your efforts in this regard.  Please get back to us with any further questions.

An Ask Extension Expert Replied February 27, 2024, 1:26 PM EST

Loading ...