Knowledgebase

Saving seeds #842703

Asked July 26, 2023, 11:45 AM EDT

Does the size of the fruit (e.g. tomato) indicate the potential size of the next generation? In other words, should I save seeds from the largest tomato on the bush (or vine) in order to get larger fruit next year?

Jackson County Oregon

Expert Response

I do not recommend you save seeds of your tomato plants. Virtually all of the tomatoes on the market today (with the possible exception of "Yellow Pear")) are hybrids. They will not breed true because they are a combination of seeds from genetically different  parents. So,we have tomatoes that are parthenocarpic ( both male and female in the same blossom) and tomatoes that are grape shaped (probably one of the parents was a cherry tomato of some kind. etc.) From these varied parents come different colors, different sizes, different ripening times,different climate requirements. (For example, "Jet Star"  is a medium sized tomato that tolerates hot sun and matures fruit earlier than some.) So, if you have a great tomato tht you want to grow again, be sure to save the tags, or write down the variety so you can repeat  your good fortune next year.
marjorie n. OSU Ext. Master Gardener Replied July 27, 2023, 9:33 PM EDT

I don't grow "hybrids", only heirlooms. So, my question still stands: Is a larger-sized "parent" specimen more likely to produce larger offspring than a smaller "paarent" specimen taken from the same plant?

The Question Asker Replied July 27, 2023, 10:04 PM EDT
I'm sorry to say that even plants sold as heirlooms may not  breed true. The tomato is a "so-called "buzz pollinator" which means that a shake, the wind, a pollinator can distribute pollen from one flower to another. if that "other" is a different tomato (i.e. not  let's say Brandywine
marjorie n. OSU Ext. Master Gardener Replied July 30, 2023, 6:22 PM EDT
(Adding because system cut me off)
If the "other" is a different tomato (let's say "Brandywine') you have seeds in the result of a fruit on the original receptor
marjorie n. OSU Ext. Master Gardener Replied July 30, 2023, 6:40 PM EDT

Let's start all over. I have ONE tomato plant: an Amish Paste Tomato. It is an heirloom variety. Some of the ripening tomatoes are much larger than the other tomatoes on the same plant. So, if I wish to save seeds, should I choose the largest fruit in hopes of propagating large fruits next year, or are all seeds going to be the same regardless of the size of the "parent" fruit?

The Question Asker Replied July 30, 2023, 7:53 PM EDT
I'm sorry i did not make myself clear. You take a risk in saving seeds from tomato varieties available in the present day, "Amish Paste" included. it is a "strain" of the original and s such has been modified. so, save the best looking tomao in terms of color, shape, size, etc and see what happens. Do not be disappointed if the resulting tomato plant does not produce exactly the same tomato as your plant is producing this 
marjorie n. OSU Ext. Master Gardener Replied July 31, 2023, 6:44 PM EDT

Loading ...