Knowledgebase
Aggressive Hive #804368
Asked August 03, 2022, 7:55 AM EDT
Kalamazoo County Michigan
Expert Response
Hi Kevin,
Thanks for reaching out with this question. I'm sorry to hear that your colony is being more defensive than you would expect.
There are many factors that can influence a colony's temperament, including genetics, weather, time of year, the beekeeper not using enough smoke in the right ways, being harassed or robbed, etc.
This is a time of year when bees are beginning to guard/defend their entrance from robber honey bees from other colonies, so they may be more defensive. It's best to not have hives open for longer than necessary, as open hives are exposed to robbing bees who typically recruit other bees to return and rob.
Do you smoke the entrance before opening the hive, and do you smoke the top of the boxes when removing the cover or hive bodies? Honey bees give off alarm pheromone when they sense a threat, which elicits other bees to give off alarm pheromone and/or sting. The elicitation of alarm pheromone can be a chain reaction in the colony, and smoke helps cover up the alarm pheromone. Using more smoke may help.
Sometimes skunks will scratch the front of the hives and feed on honey bees that leave to defend the colony. Colonies that are harassed by skunks can be more defensive. Check the front of the hive and ground near the entrance for scratches, paw prints, skunk poop, etc.
One paper found that varroa mite infestations can cause bees to be quicker to sting: Full article: The mite Varroa destructor lowers the stinging response threshold of honey bees (Apis mellifera).
Defensive behavior is a genetic trait, so you may want to consider requeening your colony (perhaps next spring) if you aren't able to find a way to manage it. Unfortunately, it can take several weeks for the new queen's daughters to replace the old queen's daughters. (Workers take 3 weeks to develop from the time the egg is laid until they emerge, and then it takes a 3-6 more weeks for the adult bees to be at the age where they are most inclined to defend the hive.)
In the short term, you could consider moving the hive to another location where it does not pose a risk to neighbors. A local Michigan Bee Club may be able to help you find a new yard. If you have questions about moving hives, feel free to reach out.
Happy beekeeping, and good luck!