Knowledgebase

Efficacy of ultrasonic deer devices #745657

Asked April 22, 2021, 11:21 AM EDT

Have used spray repellents, soap, hair, fencing, etc but my roses & gardens are a salad bar for the critters. Saw new silver deer repellent tape that u stake @ & above garden??? Thought the ultra sonic devices may b a better choice?? What has your experience been, any recommendations?? Thanks

Howard County Maryland

Expert Response

I commiserate with you. It is a problem at my house and many others. I tried most of the various methods that you mentioned (soap, urine, ultrasonics, sprays, ... ) and they did not work or became too expensive and required regular applications (e.g. sprays after rain). For a while my electric deer fence (with scent on it) worked.  I still have that in certain areas and it may shock me more often than the deer.... Then the deer population pressure increased and I had to resort to a 7-8ft heavy duty plastic deer fence around my growing areas (it's actually around my entire property), with heavy duty metal wire on top, middle and bottom along the length of the fence. I also added a 4ft metal fence along most the bottom half to keep other critters out; it does prevent deer from breaking through in those areas but they still jump over at times! There is still breakthrough during rutting in the less protected areas and branches do fall on the fence which then requires patching. The deer also come up the open driveway, so when it's not freezing outside, I use a motion activated water sprinkler to cover the non-fenced driveway and it does deter deer from entering. (It also keeps out people who do not want to get wet!) So.... if there is no homeowner association rules or covenants, you will need to resort to fencing your beds (or property) or putting bird netting over your desirable plants; the netting does sometimes catch birds and snakes. I have also started using more deer tolerant plants but they will eat those if hungry enough (lots of lists on-line). Deer taste buds vary from herd to herd! So what may work in one area may not work for another. In the winter I cover desirable plants with bird netting and have a separate netting fence around my veggie garden (double protection). To keep the cost of a fencing system reasonable, I use 4ft metal stakes (or convenient trees) about 10-20 ft apart and tie wrap 8ftx1" bamboo poles to each (the bamboo lasts a few years). I run the metal wire from pole to pole and using more tie wraps, hang and secure the heavy duty deer fencing on the wires. On the top and middle, along the fence length, I hang reflectors (or old CDs) as an additional deterrent; deer do not see very well! This approach has been 95% effective for me! (When I volunteered at Brookside Gardens, they went from 8 to 10 ft fencing since deer jumped to lower one...and had cow grates on the driveways.) I'm afraid there is no easy answer. If you cannot or do not want to install fencing or netting, then the only things which may work are 1. an electric deer fence plus scent and a motion activated sprinkler in unprotected areas, 2. deer sprays, and you have to find the ones that work for you, apply them regularly, follow all directions, and change the ones used, so the deer do not get used to one of them, and 3. several motion activated sprinklers moved regularly to different spots (watch you water bill).

Loading ...