Knowledgebase

Can you tell me if wine or whiskey barrels make a longer lasting planter? Whiskey barrels are charred more, so are they more resistant to decay? #739676

Asked March 18, 2021, 4:46 PM EDT

Can you tell me if wine or whiskey barrels are more resistant to decay as a garden planter? Whiskey barrels seem thinner and more charred. Does the burn layer slow decomposition?

Kootenai County Idaho

Expert Response

Your question is somewhat out of the area of our horticulture expertise. But my personal experience tells me that any container made of wood will eventually rot if it is wet much of the time. Whether or not the charring makes the 1/2 barrel more rot-resistant, I do not know.

If you decide use a 1/2 barrel, here are some ideas I found online slow the decay.

  • 1. Before filling with soil, drill drainage holes in the bottom the size of a quarter. Although the dry wood looks as if no drain holes are needed, the wood slats swell, closing the tiny spaces between them, when the barrel is filled with potting soil and that soil is watered regularly. Without drain holes in the wine barrel's bottom, you risk drowning the roots of plants in the barrel.
  • 2. Spray the bottom and inside of the barrel with apple cider vinegar. If your wine barrel is the real thing — solid oak that was used to ferment grapes rather than one purchased at a landscape store— it may play host to a fungus that will grow on the wood. 
  • 3. Cut pieces of wire mesh to fit over the drainage holes.
  • 4. Secure the mesh with staples if possible.
  • 5. Add casters--recommended if your barrel will sit on a patio or deck.

Whether or not to line your barrel with plastic is entirely up to you. Many people feel that a liner significantly extends a barrel’s life — though how much is questionable. One way or another, if your barrel is solid oak, it should last for a good long time.

  • You may want to line your barrels for a different reason, which is that it helps the soil to retain moisture. Even large containers can dry out quickly during a stretch of hot summer days. With a liner, you don’t have to water as often.

I hope this is helpful.

An Ask Extension Expert Replied March 19, 2021, 12:27 PM EDT
Thanks for your time and advice points. Seems not much can be found on this topic online. I did learn that charring of wood is used for siding and other exterior applications to extend life of wood. Also white oak is way more resistant to decay than red oak. All whiskey barrels are white oak and are heavily charred. So seems they would be better option compared to uncharred wine barrels. 
Thanks again,
Tony

On Fri, Mar 19, 2021 at 9:27 AM Ask Extension <<personal data hidden>> wrote:
The Question Asker Replied March 19, 2021, 1:11 PM EDT
I believe your assumptions are correct, but I have no research-based evidence.  Good luck.
An Ask Extension Expert Replied March 24, 2021, 8:45 AM EDT
Sounds like an interesting applied research project to write up in  HortTechnology! I live in the PNW, seems there are a lot of these barrels on the market now, often the two types can be found side by side. Thanks again for your assistance.
Tony


On Wed, Mar 24, 2021 at 5:45 AM Ask Extension <<personal data hidden>> wrote:
The Question Asker Replied March 24, 2021, 1:36 PM EDT

Thank you for using Ask Extension!

An Ask Extension Expert Replied April 06, 2021, 2:19 PM EDT

Loading ...