Knowledgebase

Seed saving #738660

Asked March 12, 2021, 5:39 AM EST

The Boston Pickling Cucumber's description states it is an Heirloom that is seedless. My question is how to grow it the following year if there are no seeds to save?

Oakland County Michigan

Expert Response

I cannot confirm what you have seen. But, I can tell you that the manufacture of seedless cucumbers is complicated and expensive, and usually results in plants that do not produce male flowers. Only female flowers are produced, and they will set fruit without pollination and will not make seeds. It is a dead end for seed saving.

However, they will also set fruit WITH pollination, and make seeds that can be saved. However, that pollen will have come from a male flower, and that genetic code for producing male flowers will be passed onto those seeds. Most likely, in a garden with lots of fun stuff, that pollen will come from a different variety. 

In my experience, seedless cucumbers that get pollinated are never a nice straight fruit. They are usually lumpy or pointy because there are typically not enough "off-types" producing male flowers to fully pollinate the female flowers. But, if you have lots of another variety that makes male flowers, then your seedless variety will be well-pollinated and it will have a full set of seeds and a straight fruit just like any other standard type. But, you will have probably paid extra for a seedless variety and will not have gotten the desired result.

If you save those seeds and plant them the following year, you will most likely have a mix of plants that have behaviors that are mix of the two or more varieties that cross-pollinated. Some will produce male flowers and some will not. Pollination will occur again at some level, and you will have seeded fruit again.

If you desire nice straight seedless cucumbers year after year, then you must by the specially-produced seed each year, and isolate those plants from any other variety that produces male flowers.

The way that I suspect this is considered an Heirloom is that it has been bred to produce mostly-or all-female flowers, but is chemically-induced with plant hormones or environmentally-induced with temperature/light/moisture controls to produce male flowers for the purpose of self-pollinating (open-pollinating). This reinforces the traits and produces the in-bred seed that you buy.

You can read more about cucumber flowering habits here: https://www.seminis-us.com/resources/agronomic-spotlights/understanding-flowering-habits-cucumbers/

You can get a peek into cucumber breeding with all these flowering habits here: https://european-seed.com/2020/02/the-cucumber-not-so-simple/

Ben Phillips Replied March 12, 2021, 10:40 AM EST
Thank you Ben for your quick and informative response. I learned a lot and appreciate your time.
Debbie



Sent from my Sprint Samsung Galaxy S9.


-------- Original message --------
From: Ask Extension <<personal data hidden>>
Date: 3/12/21 10:40 AM (GMT-05:00)
To: Debbie Harrison <<personal data hidden>>
Subject: Re: Seed saving (#0008592)

The Question Asker Replied March 12, 2021, 1:52 PM EST

Loading ...