Knowledgebase
adding sand to clay soil #737504
Asked January 27, 2021, 8:19 PM EST
Multnomah County Oregon
Expert Response
Thank you for choosing Ask an Expert for help with your soil issue. Please do not add sand to your clay soil. Here’s what happens: clay particles are so, so very much smaller than sand particles (though they all look pretty small to us). When sand and clay mix together, the tiny clay particles sift in between the spaces between the sandy pieces, filling them up. Then you have pretty much a solid – even worse drainage than you started with.
The organic matter is large pieces which work their way between the clay particles. Organic matter also feeds the microbes that glue clay particles together so they act like the larger sandy (better-draining) particles.
If you are having problems with vegetable growth due to soggy soils, even in summer, raising the level of the soil is a better idea. You don’t have to put sides on this “raised bed”, just add your organic matter and hill up the bed. Even four inches higher will make a difference. For more on raised beds of all kinds, check out this Oregon State Extension publication, Raised Bed Gardening, here: https://catalog.extension.oregonstate.edu/fs270
Asparagus crowns should be available at your local nursery
or garden center early in the spring, but should not be planted until soil is getting
warmer. Asparagus is also a crop that needs well-drained soil, so your idea of
added organic material, and then a raised bed might be in order here, as well. See
this article for more information – Asparagus Rewards Patience: https://extension.oregonstate.edu/news/asparagus-rewards-patience
Be sure your garden is well-fed
throughout the summer. This generally means a plant food application three
times a season. This season-long plant food program
is important for plants producing as much fruit as a tomato or squash does.
There are many choices from quick-acting to slow-release and from liquids to granules.
Compost is wonderful organic matter, but has little nutrition for vegetables.
Have a good gardening
year,
I certainly see where you’re going with the question of adding soil to your 4-way mix. However, there are enough variables at work here that are just not made clear in the research or in most people’s experience. I expect that a 4-way mix actually has some sandy loam or sand in it. Most of these mixes are just fine structurally, but they may not hold enough nutrients. My advice would be to maintain a consistent fertilizer schedule over the growing season.
One reason some plants do not develop
as we expect can be put down to unseasonable cold or warm temperatures that
entice a plant to move into another stage of growth too quickly (juvenile to
maturity and flowering, for example). Plant at the recommended time to maximize
the chance of hitting the season correctly, but we can’t control the weather.
Best planting times are usually on seed packets or found in this Oregon State
Extension publication: Growing Your Own, here: https://catalog.extension.oregonstate.edu/em9027
All the best,