Knowledgebase

A male deer rubbed his antlers on my young maple. I'm wondering if it will survive. #729016

Asked October 06, 2020, 9:18 AM EDT

There is damage on one side of the tree from a deer last night. On the other side of the tree there is damage from the same thing from last fall. I'm wondering if this tree will survive. Both damages are the same height, just on opposite sides of the tree. Also, this summer I noticed earwigs just underneath the damaged bark shown in picture #3.

Lorain County Ohio

Expert Response

With damage to two sides of the trunk, unfortunately, I think your tree will be, at best, severely compromised if it does survive.  It would be best to replace it now as fall is a good time to transplant trees and you will be surprised how quickly a new tree will grow once it settles in.  proper planting and aftercare are critical as well as protecting your new tree from deer damage.

 An excellent resource for installing new trees:


https://www.extension.purdue.edu/extmedia/fnr/fnr-433-w.pdf



Below are two good websites with information on deer rubbing damage.


https://www.uidaho.edu/-/media/UIdaho-Responsive/Files/Extension/topic/nursery/diseases/deer-antler-rubbing.pdf?la=en&hash=CCC5F57E40E50A70DE05732983A2AB4808C18F65

An excerpt:

"If the injury is only on one side of the tree, the tree has a good chance of survival, although it will be weak in that spot, and have an ugly scar. If the injury is all the way around the tree, it will most likely die."


https://www.johnson.k-state.edu/lawn-garden/agent-articles/miscellaneous/deer-damaged-trees.html


An excerpt:

Bucks like to rub their antlers on young trees, causing extensive damage to the bark, which often results in a slow death for the tree. Protecting trees from damage is essential in areas populated with deer. Unfortunately, once the damage is done, there is little that can be done to repair the tree. Most times, the tree will need to be removed. I recommend protecting all trees, deciduous and evergreen, under 6 to 8 inches in trunk diameter."

Jane Ellison Replied October 10, 2020, 1:59 PM EDT

Loading ...