Hello --
Thanks for reaching out! Unfortunately, I think it will be best for you to kill the existing lawn and then replace it with the grasses you would like. Otherwise, even if you overseed with some native grasses the end result will be a mixture of grasses (or potentially one might overtake the other slowly).
Here are some thoughts on how and why to do a full lawn renovation.
A few good reasons for a full lawn renovation (killing all the existing lawn and replacing all or some of it) include: the current lawn is frequently attacked by disease or insects, the landscape has become increasingly shady leading to a decline in lawn health, the lawn has multiple types of turf due to seeding in different spots with different seed over time, a desire to xeriscape, or to convert from one lawn species to another.
Here are some helpful tidbits on renovating the home lawn:
When:
-->Cool season grasses (bluegrass, ryegrass, fescues): The optimum time to reseed these types of grasses on the front range mid-august to mid-september.
-->Warm-season grasses (buffalo grass and blue grams): These grasses can be reseeded anytime from April -July.
Fast Fact: Your might be hesitant about getting rid of the grass in the prime season for enjoying the grass and want to push off renovating til fall. However, seeding after the first fall frost is not recommended (even for cool season grasses) because the seedlings have a chance of being winter killed.
Gettin' Rid of the Ol' Lawn:
Herbicidal:
One sure fire way to kill the existing lawn is to use a non-selective herbicide such as glyphosate. You should direct your client to carefully read the instructions on the package of herbicide. But here are some general instructions:
1. Make sure your client is aware that herbicide can drift and harm nearby plants or grasses. Those plants should be covered during application.
2. Advise your client to use a low-pressure, coarse-droplet spray with a handheld, cardboard or metal spray shield. Better yet, consider a wick-type applicator available at many garden centers.
3. Apply the herbicide when it will not rain for at least 8 hours. Allow herbicide to dry fully for one day, then resume watering for the next 10 days. Your client can spot spray the areas that are still green during this initial period. Your client might need to do a fully application a second time.
4. When the vegetation is dead, have your client mow the site to 1/2 inch and remove the debris by hand racking or using the bagging unit on a mower. Ultimately, there may be a lasting thatch (matted layer of organic matter on soil surface) layer. If this layer is under 1 inch thick, it can stay, if this layer is over 1 inch thick, it should be removed.
Non-herbicidal: If you would like a non-herbicidal alternative to killing the existing lawn, one suggestion is the newspaper and woodchips method. Your client should overlap at least 10 sheets of black and white newsprint on the lawn. This should be weighed down with 4 inches of wood chips (sprinkled with water) to keep the newspaper from blowing all over! Weigh it down with 4 inches of wood chips to keep it from blowing. After a few weeks the grass will be dead and the newspaper will begin to decompose, creating extra organic matter that is beneficial to the soil.
Another similar non-herbicidal method would be akin to soil solarization where your client could cover the entire lawn with plastic and that will heat up with the sun and ultimately also smother the grass.
Prepping the Soil for Seed:
The key to success is a good soil to seed contact ratio. So prepping the yard to increase this soil to seed ratio is key! One way to increase the success of seeds would be to core cultivate (otherwise known as aerating) the lawn. Alternatively, your client could get a great workout in by power raking the yard both directions to create a texture in the soil for better seed/soil contact.
Seeding (or Sodding?):
2. Make sure you client reads the seed labels and seeds at the recommended rate with drop spread in two directions.
3. Follow seeding with a light raking to work the seed into the soil. You should not add topsoil or sand after seeding.
Should I sod? Sod is best used to establish new lawns but can be used for renovation if existing vegetation is removed from underlying soil is tilled or core cultivated.
Watch it Grow:
1. Your can add a starter fertilizer, make sure they follow the directions on the packaging. Over-fertilizing won't be good for the seedlings.
2. Make sure the area is adequately irrigated (consistently moist, but not soggy)
3. Keep traffic off the lawn until it has been mowed a few times.
4. Mow the lawn when the grass reaches 2.5 inches down to 2 inches.
5. Wait to use re-emergent herbicides until 1 year after the lawn renovation.
Some fun fact sheets: Renovating the Home Lawn (7.241), Xeriscaping- Retrofit your Yard (7.234); Rejuvenating a Lawn (Plant Talk 1550) (Type these names into google along with "fact sheet" and you'll get these documents)
And a youtube video: