Knowledgebase
Top Dressing in Fort Collins #623022
Asked April 10, 2020, 5:01 PM EDT
Thank-you for any recommendations or suggestions you would offer.
Larimer County Colorado
Expert Response
With as old of lawn as you have, you likely have a large nightcrawler population, which is causing the lumpiness. This will continue to happen, but you can try to even things out as best you can.
If you want to topdress, which isn't a standard practice we recommend, use compost of some sort. This might be aged manure, as you suggested. DO NOT use sand. That will make things worse. Apply 1/2" to 1" over the surface and then use an aerator to go over the lawn, making lots and lots and lots of passes to work the compost into the soil.
If you have primarily bluegrass, then I would suggest you only seed bluegrass. Fine fescue isn't as tolerate to foot traffic as bluegrass. After aerating, you can seed, using 3-5 pounds of seed per 1000 square feet. If you want to use a bluegrass/perennial ryegrass mixture (commonly used for sports fields), then seed at 5-8 pounds/1000 square feet. Buy high quality seed from a nursery, garden center, or farm supply store. I would avoid bagged seed from box stores or hardware stores.
If you want to send me photos of the wide bladed grass, I can likely ID it for you. My email address is: <personal data hidden>. Please send high resolution photos. But regardless of what it is, there are no selective ways to remove it from the rest of the turf, except by spraying or digging it out. You can also learn to live with it.
I also can't ID if you have necrotic ring spot without photos. They form "frog's eye" patches of dead grass with a green middle. They aren't generally orange in color. The only "orange" I can think of with turf is rust, but that's pretty uncommon.
If you want to add topsoil, then I would try to use soil from another part of your landscape--just so you do have "like" soils and don't create a texture interface.
And the biggest difference between golf courses/sports fields versus our home lawns is those are actually built on sand. So for them to add sand is fine, since the 8-10 below the turf is already sand. But adding sand to our traditional soils will result in concrete (because of all of our clay).
Also, following aeration, leave the cores on the lawn and mow them in to add additional organic matter. Doing this will also improve the soil quality over time.
One thing you can also try...and this won't improve the actual elevation changes in the lawn...but if you just have general lumpiness, you can rent a roller, fill it with water, and roll it flat. Essentially you're compacting the soil. This is a temporary fix, but it can help short-term.