Knowledgebase

Raised bed soil recommendations #431888

Asked October 18, 2017, 2:23 PM EDT

I live in the West Hills (~350' elevation). I have new raised bed vegetable garden boxes and was wondering what soil would be good to put in them. What should I look for in soil? My boxes are 24" deep--should I fill them completely with a garden soil or use different products at different layers? How thick/deep should the topsoil be? I note that Best Buy in Town has their "Super Grow Soil Blend" -- is that a reasonable choice? Thanks.

Washington County Oregon

Expert Response

I'm assuming you plan to grow vegetables in them.  If so, you want to have close to a neutral pH (7.0) and most soil mixes will be 3-way or 4-way mixes (combination of clay/silt, sand and organic matter.)  However your boxes are really deep and depending on the size of these boxes, purchasing all topsoil can be expensive.  One trick I use in my own garden (I did this just last weekend so it's not too late) is composting straw (not hay) and 40# blood or feather meal over the winter.  My boxes are small (3'X4') and two straw bales fit nicely into them.  I then evenly spread the meal over the top and water in.  The bales are now covered with about 4" of topsoil.  It stands about 30" high (above my 24" boxes) but over the winter it will compost/compress and will be ready to plant  in early spring.

In your case, you don't need to used the whole bale but you can put a layer of 10-12" of straw and then sprinkle with the meal, then fill the remainder with soil.

Another tip is to lay down hardware cloth (19 gauge or heavier, 1/4" grid) at the bottom of your boxes prior to filling.  This prevents unwanted critters from tunneling into the boxes.

If you are go the soil route, you may want to wait until spring to purchase it unless you want to plant crops to over winter (hardneck garlic and shallots are my favorite things to overwinter.)  During the winter rain and snow may compress your soil.  You can protect it with leaves or wood chips but you will want to remove that mulch prior to planting.

Regards and happy gardening! Replied October 18, 2017, 2:44 PM EDT
Thanks for the info.  I ended up with full soil, but may use straw in the future.

What protection would be appropriate for over winter?  Is a non-permeable layer of some sort useful?--a sheet of plastic perhaps?  I know that you mentioned leaves or wood chips.  What are the benefits of covering?--I could imagine to prevent a) compaction and b) leeching of nutrients.  If to prevent leeching, I would expect something to keep water out entirely.  Thanks.
The Question Asker Replied November 18, 2017, 1:10 PM EST

You are better off with a semi-permeable covering like leaves, wood chips, even burlap is good (if you can get used burlap bags from a coffee roaster, that's a great, cheap source.)  It's really the compaction you are trying to protect against.  The rains will do some leaching, but in the spring/summer when you are planting, you may want to do a quick pH check and amend based on what you want to plant.  Peas and beans don't really need much amendment, but tomatoes really need a good dose of calcium (lime or bone meal are typical choices.)

I wouldn't recommend plastic over the winter as the likelihood of the water puddling could cause more compaction in places.  However, placing black plastic over your beds a couple of weeks prior to planting can be beneficial in warming up the soil and allowing for moderate drying out.

Regards and happy gardening! Replied November 20, 2017, 11:39 AM EST
OK, thanks.  How would newspaper do as a semi-permeable covering?
The Question Asker Replied November 20, 2017, 11:52 AM EST
Sure, but you will need to secure it.  Cardboard will also work.
Regards and happy gardening! Replied November 20, 2017, 11:56 AM EST

Loading ...