Knowledgebase

What kind of fertilizer do I use? #215959

Asked October 07, 2014, 12:21 PM EDT

I just received my test results for my soil. I need to put 3 to 4 pounds of Nitrogen, 2.8 pounds of Phosphate and 5.8 pounds of Potassium per 1000 sq feet. I also need to apply 2 pounds of 0-0-60 per square foot of Potash. What is the best and most cost efficient way to accomplish this?

Otsego County Michigan

Expert Response

There is a problem in your numbers:
3-4 lb. nitrogen
2.8 phosphorus
5.8 Potassium; all per 1000 sq. ft. of area
Then you mention two pounds of 0-0-60 which is potash or potassium.  They are the same product.  The 0-0-60 is called muriate of potash.

You can't have two potassium amounts listed.  It is either one or the other.
Why don't you send me your code for your soil test so I can see what the recommendation says?  I can't give you a recommendation until we figure out what the recommendation says.

The first listing is for products that don't exist because they are 100% pure.  Fertilizers are always percentages like 46-0-0 which is 46 percent nitrogen or 0-0-60 or 0-0-52 which have different amounts of potassium.

I am guessing that you are not going to apply fertilizer now because there is no crop to benefit.  This going to be a spring application.    The phosphorus and potassium can be all applied in the spring but the nitrogen will be divided into three or four applications during the growing season, depending on which amount you want to apply.
An Ask Extension Expert Replied October 07, 2014, 1:22 PM EDT
Thank you for your response.  Here is the results I got from the soil sample.  10/7/2014 MSU Soil Test.com - Personalized Recommendations for Your Lawn and Vegetable Garden Based On Your Soil Test Results
Soil Test (#94AD3Z) Report for Carrina Samkowiak - Garden (crop: Vegetable Garden)
Below Optimum Optimum Above Optimum
Phosphorus (P) 53 ppm
Potassium (K) 56 ppm
Magnesium (Mg) 164 ppm
Calcium (Ca) 927 ppm
CEC 6.145 meq/100 g
Soil type MINERAL , Sandy loam
Soil pH 7.4
Lime index 0
Organic Matter 2.4 %
Follow Your Personalized Recommendations
Important: Always apply fertilizers according to label instructions
Your soil test indicates you need to apply 3 to 4 lb. Nitrogen (N)/1000 sq.
feet, 2.8 lb. phosphate (P O )/1000 sq. feet and 5.8 lb. potassium (K 0)/1000
sq. feet to meet recommendations. Below are examples of fertilizers that
could be used. After you select a fertilizer, use the fertilizer calculator to
determine how much phosphorus and potassium the fertilizer you selected
will apply.
The following are typical fertilizers that can be used to satisfy the nutrient
requirements of your garden. If the particular fertilizer is not available, choose a
fertilizer close to the prescribed fertilizer and use the Fertilizer Calculator to
determine how much nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium the fertilizer you
choose applies.
Desired fertilizer ratio - 1:1:1
Analysis Fertilizer Rate
(lb/1000 ft²)
Option 1 12-12-12 30
Option 2 5-5-5 70
Option 3 2-2-2 180
Option 1. Manufactured Fertilizer: Apply 12-12-12 fertilizer at 20 pounds per 1000 sq ft before planting and till into soil. Make a second application of 12-12-
12 fertilizer at 10 pounds per 1000 sq ft 3 weeks after plants emerge and till in between the rows.
Option 1 Characteristics: More readily available for plant uptake, more concentrated form of nutrients, generally less expensive per pound of fertilizer nutrient.
OR
Option 2. Manufactured Fertilizer: Apply 5-5-5 fertilizer at 47 pounds per 1000 sq ft before planting and till into soil. Make a second application of 5-5-5
fertilizer at 23 pounds per 1000 sq ft 3 weeks after plants emerge and till in between the rows.
OR
Option 3. Natural Organic Fertilizer: Apply 2-2-2 fertilizer at 120 pounds per 1000 sq ft before planting and till into soil. Make a second application of 2-2-2
fertilizer at 60 pounds per 1000 sq ft 3 weeks after plants emerge and till in between the rows.
Option 3 Characteristics: Nutrients released more slowly, can be more expensive if high rates are needed, and can supply organic matter.
Notes:
Approximate conversion of lb of nutrient needed to cups of nutrient needed: Ground limestone (1 lb = 1 1/2 cups); Most complete fertilizers (such as 12-12-
12, 1 lb = 2 1/4 cups); Urea (46-0-0, 1 lb = 2 1/2 cups).
It is recommended that compost be applied each year to the soil after harvest and tilled in
The Question Asker Replied October 07, 2014, 3:33 PM EDT
One more thing......I thought that I needed to build the soil up this fall so it would be ready for the Spring?  Am I incorrect?  If I do build the soil up now, will it loose everything that I put into it by the Spring?
The Question Asker Replied October 07, 2014, 3:36 PM EDT
You could have just sent me the code and I can open your test.  What I see is that you can use a fertilizer with a ratio of 1:1:1 so it could be 12-12-12- or 16-16-16.

If you use 12-12-12 and you want 3 lb. of N per 1000 sq. feet, you would use 25 lb. that you divide into three applications.  If you wanted 4 lb. of N and used 12-12-12, you would use 33 lb. and divide it into four applications.

If you use 16-16-16 and you want 3 lb. of N per 1000 sq. ft., you would use 19 lb. that you divide into three applications.  If you wanted 4 lb. of N and used 16-16-16, you would use 25 lb.

You would like an organic matter percentage of 5% or above.  Add a total of four inches of compost or composted manure to the garden.  Add two inches and turn it in and then add the last two inches.  It will be there next spring.  Fertilize in the spring one or two weeks before putting in the garden.
An Ask Extension Expert Replied October 07, 2014, 3:49 PM EDT
Sorry, I didn't know I could just have given you the number.  :)  I just cut and copied it so it was not too much work.  Thank you very much.  You have been a big help.  I didn't know that I needed to divide it up into different applications.  Thank you again.

The Question Asker Replied October 07, 2014, 5:00 PM EDT
You are very welcome.  If you ever have any questions... even not about fertilizer... give me a call.  I am the horticulture Educator in Livingston County.  Gretchen... 517/546-3950
An Ask Extension Expert Replied October 08, 2014, 10:24 AM EDT
Fantastic.  Thank you.  I ALWAYS have gardening questions.  My green beans and a couple other things did not do too well at all this year and I am not sure why.  It is the first year I have ever had that happen.

Thank you for all your time and getting back to me so quickly.  I purchased some of the items I need this morning.

Carrina
The Question Asker Replied October 08, 2014, 11:38 AM EDT
Always consider that this was a cool growing season and green beans are a warm season crop. 

Other vegetables are grouped in warm season vegetables like tomatoes, peppers, eggplant, squash and corn.  The peppers seemed not to be as affected by cool weather as did tomatoes and for some people, beans.  This summer was just did not have good growing temperatures.  This is separate from diseases.
An Ask Extension Expert Replied October 08, 2014, 11:59 AM EDT
That explains some.  My tomatoes were beautiful and I had tomatoes when no one else seemed to.  The green peppers on the other hand did not fare well at all.  My daughter planted her first garden this year.  She just turning 12.  Her peppers were beautiful and no mine.  That did not make any sense to me.  It was almost like a bug or something got to the green beans and peppers.  The plants turned dark and almost dried up.  It was almost like there were black spots all over the plants.  Maybe that was a frost or something that got them???  Also my zucchini did the same thing.  I have ALWAYS had TONS of zucchini and this year, not a one.  A couple grew on the vines but the end turned yellow and they rottened out before I could harvest them.  Cucumbers on the other hand were the best I have ever had.  I planted double the crop because in past years, I was only able to get about a 70% yield.  Everyone of them came up and produced.  Needless to say, I have lots of pickles that I was able to can.

The Question Asker Replied October 08, 2014, 2:19 PM EDT
Without pictures, I am not going to be of much help.  But with squash, they can have problems with squash vine borers and extreme humidity and cold could cause little fruit to die.

Next season will be different.  But take pictures and send them to Ask an Expert if you need information.
An Ask Extension Expert Replied October 08, 2014, 2:58 PM EDT

Loading ...