Knowledgebase
Does adding calcium to soil do any good to prevent Blossom End Rot? #160346
Asked November 13, 2013, 1:40 PM EST
Love Apple Farms recommends adding egg shells and bone meal to the tomato planting hole to prevent Blossom End Rot. Well, OK, no harm no foul, but in master gardener land, we tell people that uneven watering is the main reason plants do not take up calcium. Followed by high pH (we tell people to do a soil test, and not a DIY home kit, to determine accurately their garden's pH).
I'm trying to research if egg shells and bone meal have soluble forms of calcium, since if A) the person is watering evenly and B) pH is normal (around 6.5 and anyway not higher than 7.2 for sure), and the gardener decides to add calcium to the soil, what source of calcium works? Which of those is or are sustainable? (No mining, no manufacturing, ideally generated from home compost or worm bins or local sustainable source.)
Scientific references I looked at stated that most soils have adequate amounts of calcium (and lots of other nutrients that people often add, which they don't need to).
I don't want to challenge Love Apple Farm since if I had success like she does with tomatoes, then I would get to recommend people put any ol' thing in the planting hole as long as it isn't actually bad for growing! And egg shells are free and sustainable. (Not so much the fresh fish heads and bone meal fertilizer she also recommends, ie not free, especially the fish heads, if you put in sustainably caught fish heads only.) She also recommends with weekly foliar applications of worm tea.
My experience, much more limited than Cynthia Sandberg's, is that the amount of sun, the fabulousness of compost (when I started using well composted horse manure, production of everything skyrocketed), and even watering were key in producing perfect beefsteaks. Additional fertilizing seems to be unnecessary, although adding stuff is a fun ritual, and I'm all in favor of fun rituals. One bonds with the plant, and loving the plant you're growing probably also counts for a lot. (Eliding tangent into metaphysics and nature of consciousness.) Sorry to ramble on...
You can make this public if you think it isn't too badly written but fine with me if you don't publish it or publish a severely edited version.
Marianne Mueller
volunteer with Master Gardener Program of Santa Clara County, California
Santa Clara County California
Expert Response
- Maintain the soil pH between 6.2 to 6.8 and supply adequate levels of calcium through applications of dolimitic limestone or gypsum.
- Avoid drought stress and extreme moisture fluctuations by using mulch and deep, timely irrigation once or twice a week.
- Avoid overfertilizing plants with high ammoniacal nitrogen fertilizers. Excessive nitrogen can depress the uptake of calcium.
- Foliar applications of calcium with products such as Blossom End Rot Stop, are only short term fixes and often work poorly because of poor absorption and movement to the fruit area where it is needed.