Knowledgebase

Indian lime pickles #868652

Asked May 15, 2024, 11:56 PM EDT

I am using this recipe for Indian lime pickles which I have not made before: https://www.bbcgoodfood.com/recipes/lime-pickle. The limes are cooked, combined with some salt and other spices, and left in a warm place for a couple days. Then, oil and vinegar with more spices are added. The recipe calls for a sterilized jar at the beginning (but no seal or water bath can), and for the finished product to be stored at room temp for 3 months. What are the mechanisms that keep this food safe? Is the acid from the cooked limes and salt enough to keep the bad stuff from growing? Would this result in a lactic acid fermentation similar to kimchi? Should I refrigerate them after the step where the oil is added, to be extra safe, or is that not necessary?

Yamhill County Oregon

Expert Response

Hi Shannon,

Thanks for the message. This sounds like a very interesting and flavorful recipe. I haven't made nor analyzed this recipe before, so my feedback is based on some assumptions. 

The first portion of the recipe is essentially holding the spices in a high acid solution (lime juice). Due to the pH, this is unlikely to be a fermentation, but instead just a high acid soak to support flavor extraction and uniformity of the flavor in the mixture. 
The second section is an addition of more acid and oil and some low acid ingredients which is stored at room temperature. Again, unlikely to support fermentation due to the likely very low pH, so more of a flavoring situation. 

This recipe generally doesn't match to our recommendations for acidified foods as it doesn't include any thermal processing and we generally discourage the use of oil (there are some specific exceptions). The pH of the mixtures has not been measured (or is not provided), so I can't be certain of the safety of the product. Without any thermal processing and air in the top of the jar, it is possible that the product will develop mold or yeast on top, so watch for those signs.  

Sorry to not be able to provide more clarity, but these are my thoughts on the recipe.

Thanks for using Ask Extension.
Joy
Joy Waite-Cusic Replied May 25, 2024, 12:07 PM EDT
Thank you so much Joy for the thoughtful answer. Next time I try the recipe, if I were to store it in the fridge throughout the whole process, would that ensure food safety? 

In that case, could I continue to eat it for a few months, so long as it didn’t grow mold or yeast? Or, better to treat it as a quick pickle or leftovers, and eat it within about 7 days?

Thanks,
Shannon


On May 25, 2024, at 9:07 AM, Ask Extension <<personal data hidden>> wrote:


The Question Asker Replied May 28, 2024, 11:36 PM EDT
Hi Shannon,
Storage in the refrigerator is a good idea, but it will likely take longer to get full flavor development. 
Best of luck!
Joy
Joy Waite-Cusic Replied May 31, 2024, 8:30 AM EDT

Loading ...